March 29th 2007

    Economics of Autographs


    The Detroit Free Press is running an article entitled, (Detroit baseball) "Tiger            
Autographs Get Big Bucks."

Referring to the $25 for a player's autograph, the article quotes the owner of a sports
memorabilia store as saying, ""You want to keep it affordable, but they are at the very
top edge..(The price) can't go up any higher. The market won't support it. The World
Series prices topped off. I'm hoping it drops back a little."

Recall that the St. Louis Cardinals beat the Detroit Tigers in the 2006 World Series.
Read the Article!!

Discussion-Starters for Younger Children

  • If your students could meet any one famous person, who would they want to meet? Why?

Ask your students to write two questions that they would ask this person if they could ask
him/her           
anything.


  • If your students could get the autograph of a famous person as long as they traded
    something for it, what would they trade? Assuming that the thing they would trade is not
    their most precious item, why wouldn't they trade something they like more for it? What if
    your students met somebody famous, but not as important to them. Would they still want
    his/her autograph? What would they trade for it? If they would trade differently, why
    would they do so?

If possible, select somebody whom most of the students in your class admire. Go around the
room and
ask students what they would give for an autograph from this person. Help students recognize
that
different students are willing to give up different kinds of things. Why is this the case?


  • Do your students think that they are important? Is their signature special? Help your child
    (ren) understand that every individual is important and special. Ask your students what
    they would put on the back of their card if they had a baseball card or something similar.
    What are the most important details of their lives?

Invite your students to design the back of their own baseball card. It might include: their
name; favorite
hobby; year of birth; and, favorite subject in school.


  • If your students could collect anything in the world, what would they like to collect?
    Why? If they don't want to collect something, what hobby/hobbies would they like to do
    or do they do?

This type of a question could prompt the formation of new friendships as students learn more
about one
another. Perhaps a popular student in the class has something in common with a student who
is
struggling to make friends.


Web- Resource

Check out this Online Museum of Early Baseball Memorabilia!!

Discussion-Starters for Older Students


  • Vocabulary terms to discuss: Memorabilia; Economics; "Exclusive Agreement"; and,
    "Financial Investment".


  • Ask your students why they think that people are willing to pay money for famous
    people's autographs. What is it about autographs that make them desirable?

Consider asking students to respond to the following question in an essay format: "Should
people pay
professional athletes money for autographs when they could donate the money to help
provide food for
the poor?" Why/why not? Prompt students to consider whether or not paying for autographs in
any way
helps the poor.

  • Ask your students what variables they think would determine how much a store would
    charge for an autographed baseball? What variables would determine how much an
    individual would be willing to pay for an autographed baseball?

Consider asking students to respond to these questions using a T-Chart in groups of two or
three.


  • If your students could have the autograph of any one person who lived at least 100 years
    ago,who's would they select? Why? If your students could speak to this person for five
    minutes, what would they discuss?

Students could develop imaginary conversations.

  • Do your students think that this topic is appropriate for a current event newsletter?
    Why/why not? Is this topic important? Why/why not?

These questions could prompt an interesting class discussion.